Course Syllabus
Obiettivi
Comprensione delle principali questioni relative allo studio degli oceani e degli spazi transnazionali secondo la prospettiva delle geopolitica critica.
Capacità avanzata di analisi critica e di comprensione della letteratura scientifica e delle narrative relative agli oceani, e delle dinamiche geopolitiche in atto per la conquista del sea-power.
Comprensione delle pricipali sfide (acidificazione, estrazione di petrolio e gas, pesca eccessiva, attività minerarie, bio-propsecting, geoingegneria) per la gestione dei fondali marini profondi.
Abilità di condurre studi e ricerche interdisciplinari.
Contenuti sintetici
Dopo una breve introduzione sugli approcci più recenti alla geografia politica e alla geopolitica critica, il corso si concentra dapprima sulla rappresentazione storica dell’oceano come “spazio politico e sociale” e su come il mare possa essere inquadrato dal discorso geopolitico internazionale, in relazione ai processi di territorializzazione, di geo-power e di extra-territorialità degli spazi marini. La seconda parte del corso riguarda la geopolitica dei fondali marini profondi, e si focalizza in particolare su definizioni, valori, diritti di proprietà, accesso, stato di salute e futura condizione dei fondali marini, una dimensione degli oceani ricca di riserva e sempre più contesa e contestata.
Programma esteso
Elena dell’Agnese
Parte I - Political geography of
the sea
The political geography of the sea: a classical
approach (maritime boundaries and Law of the Sea, transport and trade, strategy
and warfare)
A (critical) political geo-graphy of the sea? thinking about the sea / representing the sea / exploiting the “geopolitical
features” of the sea
Geo-graphy
and the power of representation /Dividing
(and naming) the ocean sea: the East Sea/ Sea of Japan issue
The territorialisation of the sea /Territorial
claims and islands disputes: the Dokdo-Takeshima issue
Geographical
definitions and island disputes: the Sankeku-Diaoyu issue/ climate change and
vanishing islands/reefs: Okininotori: a shima, or a reef’?
A classical
approach to the geopolitics of the sea/ the myth of sea power: A.T. Mahan
theoretical positions / China as a maritime power and the South China Sea
competition (Spratly, Paracel and more)
Sea power,
sea nodes and islands as U.S. bases: The Hawai’i
and Pearl Harbor, Midway and Wake, Guam
Sea power,
sea nodes and islands as overseas U.S. bases/ bases of empire and lily pads: Guantanamo,
Micronesia and Marshall Islands, Okinawa, Diego Garcia
LSMPAs
(Large Scale Maritime Protected Areas): conservation or geopolitics?
Extra-territoriality
1: Pirates as enemies of all nations The golden age of piracy and the “pirate
commonwealth” against the “world political map”, pirates of today, popular
geopolitics of “pirates”
Extra-territoriality 3: Seasteading: “How Floating Nations Will Restore the Environment, Enrich the Poor, Cure the Sick, and Liberate Humanity from Politicians” (maybe)
Extra-territoriality 2: Cruising ships: Cruise tourism as an example of globalization? (History and Development, Crews, Employment, exploitation)
Prerequisiti
Adeguata conoscenza delle scienze sociali rilevanti (geografia, scienza politica, economia, diritto, sociologia).
Capacità di lavoro secondo prospettive multidisciplinari e interdisciplinari.
Modalità didattica
asynchronous lectures
Materiale didattico
Elena dell’Agnese
Parte I - Political geography of the sea
1. The political geography of the sea: a classical approach (maritime boundaries and Law of the Sea, transport and trade, strategy and warfare)
Glassner M.I., The new political geography of the sea, Political Geography Quarterly, 1986, pp. 6-8
A (critical) political geo-graphy of the sea? (thinking about the sea / representing the sea / exploiting the “geopolitical features” of the sea)
Steinberg, P.E. (1999) Navigating to Multiple Horizons: Toward a Geography of Ocean-Space, The Professional Geographer, 51, 3, pp. 366-375
2. Geo-graphy and the power of representation: The geo-graphy of the ocean sea / Dividing (and naming) the ocean sea
Steinberg, P.E. (1999), Lines of divison, lines of connection: Stewardship in the world ocean, Geographical Review 89, 2, pp. 254-264
The East sea/ Sea of Japan case study
Chi Sang-Hyun, One feature, two names and many issues: The political geographies of naming the sea between Korea and Japan, eastsea1994.org/data/bbsData/14912842071.pdf
3. The “political geography of the sea”: the territorialisation of the sea
Territorial claims and islands disputes (Dokdo-Takeshima)
Suk Kyoon Kim (2008), Understanding Maritime Disputes in Northeast Asia: Issues and Nature, Int'l J. Marine & Coastal L., pp. 213-247
4. Geographical definitions and island disputes (Sankeku-Diaoyu)
McCormack G. (2013), Much Ado over Small Islands: The Sino-Japanese Confrontation over Senkaku/Diaoyu, The Asia-Pacific Journal, 11, 21, pp. 1-20
climate change and vanishing islands/reefs (Okininotori: a shima, or a reef’?)
Yamamoto L., Esteban M. (2010), Vanishing Island States and sovereignty, Ocean & Coastal Management 53, pp. 1–9
5. A classical approach to the geopolitics of the sea: the myth of sea power (A.T. Mahan)
Sumida J. (1999): Alfred Thayer Mahan, geopolitician, Journal of Strategic Studies, 22, 2-3, 39-62
China as a maritime power and the South China Sea competition
Nohara J.J. (2017) Sea power as a dominant paradigm: the rise of China’s new strategic identity, Journal of Contemporary East Asia Studies, 6, 2, pp. 210-232
6. Sea power, sea nodes and islands as U.S. bases
The Hawai’i and Pearl Harbor, Midway and Wake, Guam
Vine D., (2015) Base Nation: How U.S. Military Bases Abroad Harm America and the World, Metropolitan Books, New York, Introduction, Capp. 1 and 2
7. Sea power, sea nodes and islands as overseas U.S. bases: bases of empire and lily pads
Guantanamo, Micronesia and Marshall Islands, Okinawa, Diego Garcia
Vine D., (2015) Base Nation: How U.S. Military Bases Abroad Harm America and the World, Metropolitan Books, New York, Cap 3.
8. LSMPAs (Large Scale Maritime Protected Areas): conservation or geopolitics?
Sand P.H. (2012), ‘Marine protected areas’ off UK overseas territories: comparing the South Orkneys Shelf and the Chagos Archipelago, The Geographical Journal, 178, 3, pp. 201–207
Leenhardt P., Cazalet B., Salvat B., Claudet J., Feral F. (2013). The rise of large-scale marine protected areas: Conservation or geopolitics? Ocean & Coastal Management, 85, pp. 112-118
9. Extra-territoriality 1: Pirates as enemies of all nations The golden age of piracy and the “pirate commonwealth” against the “world political map”, pirates of today, popular geopolitics of “pirates”
Featherstone D. (2005) Atlantic networks, antagonisms and the formation of subaltern political identities, Social & Cultural Geography, 6, 3, pp. 387-404
Hastings J.V., (2008), Geographies of state failure and sophistication in maritime piracy hijackings, Political Geography 28, pp. 213–223
10. Extra-territoriality 2: Cruising ships: Cruise tourism as an example of globalization? (History and Development, Crews, Employment, exploitation)
Hall C.M., (2001), Trends in ocean and coastal tourism: the end of the last frontier? Ocean & Coastal Management, 44, pp. 601-618
11. Extra-territoriality 3: Seasteading: “How Floating Nations Will Restore the Environment, Enrich the Poor, Cure the Sick, and Liberate Humanity from Politicians” (maybe)
Steinberg P.E., (2009) Sovereignty, Territory, and the Mapping of Mobility: A View from the Outside, Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 99:3, 467-495,
Steinberg P.E., Nyman E., Caraccioli M.J. (2012), Atlas Swam: Freedom, Capital, and Floating Sovereignties in the Seasteading Vision, Antipode, 44, 4, pp. 1532–1550Periodo di erogazione dell'insegnamento
Secondo semestre
Modalità di verifica del profitto e valutazione
Elena dell'Agnese
Parte I - Political geography of
the sea
Paper 2000-2500 and oral dicussions
Orario di ricevimento
Elena dell'Agnese
martedì 2,30-4,30 PM
Stanza 358/U7 terzo piano
Aims
Understanding of the main questions raised by studying oceanic and transnational spaces in a critical geopolitics perspective.
An advanced ability to critically analyze and interrogate scholarship and discourse framing the oceans, and the geopolitical dynamics underway to conquer sea-power.
An understanding of the major challenges (acidification, oil and gas drilling, overfishing, and, in the long term, deep-sea mining, bioprospecting, and geo-engineering) posed by the deep seabed.
An engagement with the challenges of inter-disciplinary study and research.
Contents
After a short introduction to the most recent theoretical approaches to political geography and critical geopolitics, the course focuses first on the historical representation of the ocean as a "political and social space" and on how the sea can be framed by international geopolitical discourse, in relation to the processes of territorialisation, geo-power and extra-territoriality of marine spaces. The second part relates to the geopolitics of the deep see and in particular it focuses on the definition, value, ownership, access, health and future state of the resource-rich and highly contested sub-surface ocean.
Detailed program
Elena dell’Agnese
Part I - Political geography of the sea
The political geography of the sea: a classical approach (maritime boundaries and Law of the Sea, transport and trade, strategy and warfare)
A (critical) political geo-graphy of the sea? thinking about the sea / representing the sea / exploiting the “geopolitical features” of the sea
Geo-graphy and the power of representation /Dividing (and naming) the ocean sea: the East Sea/ Sea of Japan issue
The territorialisation of the sea /Territorial claims and islands disputes: the Dokdo-Takeshima issue
Geographical definitions and island disputes: the Sankeku-Diaoyu issue/ climate change and vanishing islands/reefs: Okininotori: a shima, or a reef’?
A classical approach to the geopolitics of the sea/ the myth of sea power: A.T. Mahan theoretical positions / China as a maritime power and the South China Sea competition (Spratly, Paracel and more)
Sea power, sea nodes and islands as U.S. bases: The Hawai’i and Pearl Harbor, Midway and Wake, Guam
Sea power, sea nodes and islands as overseas U.S. bases/ bases of empire and lily pads: Guantanamo, Micronesia and Marshall Islands, Okinawa, Diego Garcia
LSMPAs (Large Scale Maritime Protected Areas): conservation or geopolitics?
Extra-territoriality 1: Pirates as enemies of all nations The golden age of piracy and the “pirate commonwealth” against the “world political map”, pirates of today, popular geopolitics of “pirates”
Extra-territoriality 3: Seasteading: “How Floating Nations Will Restore the Environment, Enrich the Poor, Cure the Sick, and Liberate Humanity from Politicians” (maybe)
Extra-territoriality 2: Cruising ships: Cruise tourism as an example of globalization? (History and Development, Crews, Employment, exploitation)
Prerequisites
An adequate grasp of the perspectives of the relevant social sciences (geography, politics, economics, law, and sociology).
Capacity of working according to multidisciplinary and interdisciplinary perspectives.
Teaching form
asynchronous lectures
Textbook and teaching resource
Elena dell’Agnese
Part I - Political geography of the sea
1. Political geography, geopolitics, critical geopolitics.
The political geography of the sea: a classical approach (maritime boundaries and Law of the Sea, transport and trade, strategy and warfare)
Glassner M.I., The new political geography of the sea, Political Geography Quarterly, 1986, pp. 6-8
A (critical) political geo-graphy of the sea? (thinking about the sea / representing the sea / exploiting the “geopolitical features” of the sea)
Steinberg, P.E. (1999) Navigating to Multiple Horizons: Toward a Geography of Ocean-Space, The Professional Geographer, 51, 3, pp. 366-375
2. Geo-graphy and the power of representation: The geo-graphy of the ocean sea
Dividing (and naming) the ocean sea
Steinberg, P.E. (1999), Lines of divison, lines of connection: Stewardship in the world ocean, Geographical Review 89, 2, pp. 254-264
The East sea/ Sea of Japan case study
Chi Sang-Hyun, One feature, two names and many issues: The political geographies of naming the sea between Korea and Japan, eastsea1994.org/data/bbsData/14912842071.pdf
3. The “political geography of the sea”: the territorialisation of the sea
Territorial claims and islands disputes (Dokdo-Takeshima)
Suk Kyoon Kim (2008), Understanding Maritime Disputes in Northeast Asia: Issues and Nature, Int'l J. Marine & Coastal L., pp. 213-247
4. Geographical definitions and island disputes (Sankeku-Diaoyu)
McCormack G. (2013), Much Ado over Small Islands: The Sino-Japanese Confrontation over Senkaku/Diaoyu, The Asia-Pacific Journal, 11, 21, pp. 1-20
climate change and vanishing islands/reefs (Okininotori: a shima, or a reef’?)
Yamamoto L., Esteban M. (2010), Vanishing Island States and sovereignty, Ocean & Coastal Management 53, pp. 1–9
5. A classical approach to the geopolitics of the sea: the myth of sea power (A.T. Mahan)
Sumida J. (1999): Alfred Thayer Mahan, geopolitician, Journal of Strategic Studies, 22, 2-3, 39-62
China as a maritime power and the South China Sea competition
Nohara J.J. (2017) Sea power as a dominant paradigm: the rise of China’s new strategic identity, Journal of Contemporary East Asia Studies, 6, 2, pp. 210-232
6. Sea power, sea nodes and islands as U.S. bases
The Hawai’i and Pearl Harbor, Midway and Wake, Guam
Vine D., (2015) Base Nation: How U.S. Military Bases Abroad Harm America and the World, Metropolitan Books, New York, Introduction, Capp. 1 and 2
7. Sea power, sea nodes and islands as overseas U.S. bases: bases of empire and lily pads
Guantanamo, Micronesia and Marshall Islands, Okinawa, Diego Garcia
Vine D., (2015) Base Nation: How U.S. Military Bases Abroad Harm America and the World, Metropolitan Books, New York, Cap 3.
8. LSMPAs (Large Scale Maritime Protected Areas): conservation or geopolitics?
Sand P.H. (2012), ‘Marine protected areas’ off UK overseas territories: comparing the South Orkneys Shelf and the Chagos Archipelago, The Geographical Journal, 178, 3, pp. 201–207
Leenhardt P., Cazalet B., Salvat B., Claudet J., Feral F. (2013). The rise of large-scale marine protected areas: Conservation or geopolitics? Ocean & Coastal Management, 85, pp. 112-118
9. Extra-territoriality 1: Pirates as enemies of all nations The golden age of piracy and the “pirate commonwealth” against the “world political map”, pirates of today, popular geopolitics of “pirates”
Featherstone D. (2005) Atlantic networks, antagonisms and the formation of subaltern political identities, Social & Cultural Geography, 6, 3, pp. 387-404
Hastings J.V., (2008), Geographies of state failure and sophistication in maritime piracy hijackings, Political Geography 28, pp. 213–223
10. Extra-territoriality 2: Cruising ships: Cruise tourism as an example of globalization? (History and Development, Crews, Employment, exploitation)
Hall C.M., (2001), Trends in ocean and coastal tourism: the end of the last frontier? Ocean & Coastal Management, 44, pp. 601-618
11. Extra-territoriality 3: Seasteading: “How Floating Nations Will Restore the Environment, Enrich the Poor, Cure the Sick, and Liberate Humanity from Politicians” (maybe)
Steinberg P.E., (2009) Sovereignty, Territory, and the Mapping of Mobility: A View from the Outside, Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 99:3, 467-495,
Steinberg P.E., Nyman E., Caraccioli M.J. (2012), Atlas Swam: Freedom, Capital, and Floating Sovereignties in the Seasteading Vision, Antipode, 44, 4, pp. 1532–1550Semester
Second Semester
Assessment method
Elena dell'Agnese
Parte I - Political geography of the sea
2,000-2,500 word paper on an issue analyzed during the course and selected by the instructor.Office hours
Elena dell'Agnese
by appointment, in person or online; contact the lecturer on the e-mail address
Key information
Staff
-
Elena Dell'Agnese
-
Marco Grasso